Myth or fact

What guides, guidebooks, and friends say about Portugal. Can you tell what’s true? Behind every answer is one of my stories.

Porto#

Rowling imagined Hogwarts from the staircase of the Lello bookstore

Answer

Myth

Rowling herself wrote in 2020 that she had never been there. The legend grew out of her living in Porto in the early 1990s.

The Bookstore J.K. Rowling Never VisitedRead the full story →
Paimogo beach, Lourinhã#

Dinosaur eggs are almost never found

Answer

Myth

They turn up often. What is rare is embryos inside: fragile bones rarely survive. At Paimogo, the silt from a flood preserved them.

Cape Espichel, Sesimbra#

The footprints at Cape Espichel were left by the Virgin’s mule

Answer

Myth

Legend says a mule carried the Virgin up the cliff. The trackways were actually left by sauropods about 150 million years ago.

Miragaia, Lourinhã#

All stegosaurs had short necks

Answer

Myth

No: Portugal’s Miragaia longicollum had at least 17 vertebrae in its neck, more than most sauropods. What it was for, nobody knows for sure.

Côa Valley, Vila Nova de Foz Côa#

Portugal canceled a dam to save prehistoric rock art

Answer

Fact

In 1995, work on the Côa dam was halted so Stone Age engravings would not be flooded. Today they are a UNESCO World Heritage Site.

Murça#

The Pig of Murça was carved by the Romans

Answer

Myth

No: such animals are older than the Romans and were carved by local tribes. The Romans only added inscriptions to some. Nobody knows for sure what they were for.

Lusitania#

Viriathus’s killers were told, “Rome does not pay traitors”

Answer

Partly

So tradition says, but Appian differs: Caepio paid them part of the money and sent them to Rome for the rest.

Lisbon, Rua da Prata#

Lisbon’s Roman galleries are kept flooded on purpose

Answer

Fact

The water helps hold up the houses above, and without it the structures could suffer. So it is pumped out only twice a year.

Évora#

The Roman temple in Évora is the Temple of Diana

Answer

Myth

A Portuguese priest came up with the name in the 17th century, and archaeology doesn’t support it. The temple was most likely dedicated to Emperor Augustus.

Lisbon (Olisipo)#

Under a Lisbon bank lies a Roman fish sauce factory

Answer

Fact

Yes: in 1991, during the bank’s renovation, workers found Roman vats for fish and garum sauce. The find was not buried again, and it is now a museum.

Aljustrel (Vipasca)#

In the Roman baths, women paid twice what men did

Answer

Fact

By the law on the bronze tablets of Vipasca, a man paid half a coin and a woman a whole one. Historians argue over why.

Chaves (Aquae Flaviae)#

The people of Chaves paid for their Roman bridge themselves

Answer

Fact

Yes: a column in the middle of the bridge says the citizens of Aquae Flaviae built the stone bridge at their own expense.

São Jorge plateau, Aljubarrota#

At Aljubarrota, French knights rode straight into wolf pits

Answer

Partly

So Froissart writes. Neither Ayala, an eyewitness, nor Fernão Lopes, writing sixty years later, describes the pits. It is the account of a single source.

Porto, the Douro shipyards#

Porto’s people are “tripe eaters” because they gave the fleet their meat

Answer

Partly

So the legend of 1415 goes. The chronicles don’t mention it, and by another version the nickname is thirty years older. The dish is real.

Cape Bojador (Western Sahara)#

Nobody could return from beyond Cape Bojador

Answer

Myth

The fear was an invention: in 1434 Gil Eanes rounded the cape, came back alive and brought “roses of Saint Mary.” They say he simply sailed farther out to sea.

Braga#

Cabral took Brazil for an island

Answer

Fact

Yes: Cabral took the new land for an island and named it the Island of the True Cross. The first thing the sailors saw was a mountain, Monte Pascoal.

Lisbon#

Portugal’s secret map of the world was found in a butcher shop

Answer

Fact

In 1859 a revolt looted the palace, and the library’s director found the Cantino map in a butcher shop, pasted onto a screen.

Malacca (Melaka), the bridge over the river#

The sultan of Malacca’s war elephants turned on his own army

Answer

Fact

The Portuguese met them with spears. A wounded elephant turned back, and the rest trampled their own side in panic. Sources disagree on the numbers.

Rome, the Vatican#

Roman doctors treated the sick elephant with a laxative containing gold

Answer

Fact

Yes: in the summer of 1516 the elephant Hanno fell ill, doctors gave him a laxative with gold, and he died on June 8. The pope was at his side.

Lisbon, Paço da Ribeira (now Praça do Comércio)#

Dürer drew his famous rhinoceros from life

Answer

Myth

No: Dürer never saw the rhinoceros. He worked from a sketch and a merchant’s description, hence the extra horn on the animal’s shoulder.

Salga Bay, Terceira Island#

Islanders beat back a Spanish landing with a herd of bulls

Answer

Fact

In 1581 on Terceira, a monk named Pedro proposed sending the bulls at the enemy. Their line broke, and the Spanish fled to their boats.

Portugal#

A pastry cook posed as the lost King Sebastian, and was believed

Answer

Fact

Yes: the pastry cook of Madrigal fooled even a nun of royal blood, Sebastian’s cousin. He was exposed, like the other impostors.

Lisbon, Ribeira Palace#

Portugal became independent in a single morning, on December 1, 1640

Answer

Partly

Power changed hands in a morning: the conspirators arrested the Spanish regent and proclaimed John IV. But the war with Spain lasted another 28 years.

Vila Viçosa, Sanctuary of Our Lady of the Conception#

Portugal’s kings were not crowned after 1646

Answer

Fact

So it is believed: King John IV offered his crown to the Virgin Mary, and later kings were only proclaimed, with the crown laid beside them on a cushion.

England#

A Portuguese princess made tea fashionable in England

Answer

Fact

Catherine of Braganza, who became queen of England, drank tea every day, and the court followed her. Tea was already sold in London, but she made it fashionable.

Setúbal#

The cod for bacalhau is caught off the coast of Portugal

Answer

Myth

Cod lives in the cold northern seas. The Portuguese sailed to Newfoundland for it, and today most bacalhau in Portugal is Norwegian.

Porto#

Franciscans, sworn to poverty, covered their own church in gold

Answer

Partly

It is their church, but the Third Order paid for the carving, a brotherhood of rich lay merchants. By some accounts about 400 kilograms of gold went into it.

Mafra#

The bells of Mafra are tuned to play melodies

Answer

Fact

Yes: nearly a hundred bells were ordered from Flanders and chosen by tone, like one huge instrument. By tradition, the king doubled the price himself.

Coimbra#

Students were jailed beneath Coimbra’s gilded library

Answer

Fact

Yes: the university tried its own people, and until 1834 the jail under the library held students and even professors, briefly, for misconduct.

Lisbon#

Lisbon’s palaces had servants made of tile standing by the stairs

Answer

Fact

Yes, these are figuras de convite, “welcome figures”: life-size tile footmen and ladies greeted guests at the entrance and on the stairs.

Lisbon, Church of São Roque#

A chapel was built in Rome, taken apart and shipped to Lisbon

Answer

Fact

Yes: the finished chapel was blessed by the pope, then taken apart into 174 pieces. Three ships carried them to Lisbon, where it was put together again.

Lisbon, Alfama#

For centuries, Spaniards carried water to Lisbon’s homes

Answer

Fact

Mostly Galicians from northern Spain: a barrel on the shoulder, from the public fountain to the customer’s door, until piped water arrived.

Douro Valley (Alto Douro)#

18th-century port wine was dyed with elderberry juice

Answer

Fact

Yes: when there was too much wine, the weak wine was colored with elderberry so it looked thick and dark. Later the elder trees in the valley were pulled out.

Mafra, National Palace#

Bats guard the books in the Mafra library

Answer

Partly

The bats are real and hunt paper-eating insects at night. But no one has measured how long they have been there or how much they help the books.

Lisbon, the arcades of Terreiro do Paço (now Praça do Comércio)#

In 18th-century Lisbon, the ice was hauled from the mountains by oxen

Answer

Fact

Yes: snow was gathered in the Serra da Estrela, packed down in pits and carried by oxen and donkeys to the Tagus, then by boat to Lisbon.

Cachão da Valeira, Douro#

Port wine went to the sea by road along the Douro

Answer

Myth

There were no roads along the steep banks: casks floated downriver on rabelo boats, and for them a rock was even broken up in the Valeira gorge.

Upper Alentejo: Elvas, Campo Maior, Olivença#

Godoy sent the queen a branch of oranges from the battlefield

Answer

Partly

It is a tradition, not a documented fact. Portuguese sources write of a branch of orange blossoms; Spanish and English ones, of oranges.

Lisbon, Belém#

A European empire was once ruled from its own colony

Answer

Fact

Yes: the court fled Napoleon, and for thirteen years Rio de Janeiro was the empire’s capital. It is the only case of a European monarchy ruling from its colony.

Borodino, Russia#

Portuguese soldiers reached Borodino in Napoleon’s army

Answer

Fact

Yes: the Portuguese Legion, about 9,000 men, fought at Wagram and in 1812 marched into Russia, to Smolensk and Borodino. Few survived.

Lisbon, Belém#

Nuns starched clothes with egg whites and used the yolks for sweets

Answer

Myth

Historian João Pedro Gomes calls it a tall tale: there is no written evidence. “Convent pastry” is largely a 19th-century myth.

Sintra#

Pena Palace was built from scratch as a fairy-tale castle

Answer

Myth

No: in 1838 King Ferdinand II bought an abandoned monastery and added towers and walls to it. The colors were restored only in 1994.

Lisbon, Mouraria#

Portugal’s first sound film was about a fado singer

Answer

Fact

“A Severa” (1931) is about Maria Severa, a singer from Lisbon’s taverns who died in 1846. There are hardly any documents about her, but plenty of legends.

Funchal, Madeira#

Madeira embroidery was made in big factories

Answer

Myth

Nobody built workshops: tens of thousands of embroiderers worked at home, were brought fabric with the pattern, and the finished work was collected.

Monte, Funchal#

The wicker sleds of Monte were invented as a tourist attraction

Answer

Myth

No: in the 19th century the villagers themselves rode them down into town, and the drivers carried freight too. They became an attraction only later.

Porto, Douro River#

Eiffel’s firm built the Maria Pia Bridge in Porto

Answer

Fact

The bridge was ordered from Gustave Eiffel’s Paris firm. Its 160-meter arch was the longest in the world, twelve years before the tower.

Funchal, Madeira#

The ukulele was invented in Hawaii

Answer

Partly

It really was made in Hawaii, but by Madeiran carpenters, who took the body of the braguinha and the tuning of the rajão. Hawaiians gave it the name.

Braga, Bom Jesus do Monte#

The funicular in Braga runs on water, with no motor

Answer

Fact

The upper car’s tank is filled with water, so it gets heavier, rolls down, and pulls the lower car up. It still has no motor today.

Lisbon#

Portugal’s anthem was written in one night in answer to England’s ultimatum

Answer

Fact

After Britain’s ultimatum of 1890, Keil and Mendonça wrote the march in a night. The monarchy banned it; the republic made it the anthem in 1911.

Palmela#

Portugal’s first car hit a donkey on its very first trip

Answer

Fact

Near Palmela, on the way from Lisbon to Santiago do Cacém in 1895. It’s considered the country’s first car accident.

Lisbon, Baixa and Chiado#

Eiffel built the Santa Justa Lift in Lisbon

Answer

Myth

It was designed by Raoul Mesnier du Ponsard, a Portuguese engineer of French descent. The lacy ironwork in Eiffel’s style gave rise to the legend.

Lisbon, Praça da Figueira#

Bolo-rei is named after a Portuguese king

Answer

Myth

Most likely not: the recipe came from France, where a similar cake is baked for Epiphany, and the “king” in the name is the Magi.

South Atlantic#

Flying from Lisbon to Rio in 1922 took three airplanes

Answer

Fact

Yes: the first crashed into the waves off the Saint Peter and Saint Paul Rocks, the second came down with engine trouble. The third reached Rio after 79 days.

Torres Vedras#

At the Torres Vedras Carnival, the queen is played by a man

Answer

Fact

Yes, by tradition: since 1924 the queen has been a man, and the pair is followed by “ministers” and matrafonas. The carnival king reigns for four days.

Heard something else you’d like checked? Tell me →